Timing: when the clock starts
Two 2025 decisions, one in each of the largest regimes, settled a question that many contracts tried to answer for themselves: if a claim arrives after hours or on a weekend, when does the time to respond begin?
Roberts Co (NSW) v Sharvain Facades
[2025] NSWCA 161, affirming [2025] NSWSC 606
A façade subcontractor uploaded a claim of about $3.2 million to the contract's online claims platform at 7:18pm on Friday 28 February 2025. The subcontract said notices given after 5pm were received at 9am the next business day. Relying on that, the head contractor counted from Monday 3 March and gave its payment schedule on 17 March. Counting from the Friday, the 10 business days ended on 14 March. The schedule was late, and the subcontractor was entitled to judgment for the claimed amount.
Lesson: a contract can shorten the time to give a schedule, but it can't buy extra time. Count from when the claim actually arrived.
Co-Operative Bulk Handling v Martinus Rail
[2026] WASCA 82, affirming Martinus Rail v Co-Operative Bulk Handling [2025] WASC 373
A rail contractor emailed a claim of about $22.6 million to the principal's representative on the afternoon of Saturday 31 August 2024. It wasn't opened until Monday. The principal gave its schedule on 24 September, but the 15 business days had ended on Friday 20 September. The courts held that the WA Electronic Transactions Act decides when an emailed claim is given: when it can be retrieved at the designated address, which was the Saturday. A contract clause deeming later receipt didn't change that.
Lesson: an unread inbox doesn't stop the clock. Someone has to see every claim the day it lands, weekends included.
Validity: what makes a claim count
Southern Han Breakfast Point v Lewence Construction
[2016] HCA 52
After taking work out of a contractor's hands, the principal argued that no reference date had arisen for the contractor's next claim. The High Court agreed that, under the NSW Act as it then stood, an available reference date was a precondition to a valid payment claim. Without one, the adjudicator had no jurisdiction.
Lesson: claim only when the Act and contract allow. NSW changed its Act in October 2019 so claims can be made on and from the last day of each month, and after termination, and Victoria removed reference dates in April 2026. The one-claim-per-period rule still matters everywhere.
Brodyn v Davenport, and Chase Oyster Bar v Hamo Industries
[2004] NSWCA 394; [2010] NSWCA 190
Brodyn held that an adjudicator's determination is void only if a “basic and essential requirement” of the Act is missing, or there is no good faith attempt to exercise the power. Chase Oyster Bar reframed that as jurisdictional error and held that a claim served outside the time the Act allows gives the adjudicator no power to decide it.
Lesson: get the basics right every time: the right parties, the work identified, the amount stated, the Act named, served within time. Defects in these are the ones that can undo a determination.
Finality: when an adjudication sticks
Probuild Constructions v Shade Systems, and Maxcon Constructions v Vadasz
[2018] HCA 4; [2018] HCA 5
In Probuild (NSW), the head contractor asked the Supreme Court to quash a determination for an error of law the adjudicator had made within jurisdiction. The High Court said the NSW Act doesn't allow that: only jurisdictional error can be challenged. Maxcon reached the same result under the South Australian Act, the same day.
Lesson: treat adjudication as final for cash flow. The payment schedule and adjudication response are where a respondent wins or loses, so the reasons and evidence need to be there, not saved for court.
What the cases have in common
None of these disputes turned on how good the work was. They turned on records:
- When exactly did the claim arrive, and did anyone see it?
- Was the claim allowed on that date, and did it say what the Act requires?
- Did the schedule go out in time, with every reason for paying less?
- Was the evidence for those reasons written down when the work was inspected?
Those are problems a system can solve. They depend on timestamps, calendars and evidence tied to the work, which is exactly what tends to get lost between an inbox, a spreadsheet and a site diary.
How Infrasis helps
Every claim has a served time
Claims served in Infrasis are stamped when they arrive, and claims received by email are recorded with their arrival time. Deadlines count from that moment, in the job's time zone.
Deadlines that know the calendar
Schedule and payment dates are counted in business days for the contract's state, skipping public holidays and the Christmas shutdown. The head contractor and the trade are both notified.
Valid claims by default
Claims carry the state's required wording, and Infrasis allows one claim per contract per month.
Reasons backed by site records
The draft schedule sets each claimed line against progress reported on site, inspection results and open defects, each with a name, a time and photos. A late schedule is marked late.
Questions
Do these cases apply in my state?
The High Court decisions apply to Acts in the same form, and the timing cases are persuasive elsewhere, but each state's Act differs. The WA decision turned on WA's electronic transactions law. Check with a lawyer for your contract.
What should we do about deeming clauses in our contracts?
Don't rely on them to extend the time for a payment schedule. Count from when the claim actually arrived, and make sure someone watches the nominated address every day.
Can Infrasis stop us missing a schedule deadline?
It shows the deadline as soon as a claim is served or recorded, notifies both parties and drafts the schedule from site records. A person still has to issue the schedule before the date.
These summaries are general information, not legal advice, and leave out much of each judgment. Read the decisions, and get advice on your contract. For the deadlines themselves, see security of payment deadlines by state.
Sources
- Roberts Co (NSW) Pty Ltd v Sharvain Facades Pty Ltd [2025] NSWCA 161 (Clayton Utz summary)
- Martinus Rail v Co-Operative Bulk Handling [2025] WASC 373 (HSF Kramer summary)
- Co-Operative Bulk Handling v Martinus Rail [2026] WASCA 82 (Allens summary)
- Southern Han Breakfast Point Pty Ltd v Lewence Construction Pty Ltd [2016] HCA 52
- Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4
- Maxcon Constructions Pty Ltd v Vadasz [2018] HCA 5
- Brodyn Pty Ltd v Davenport [2004] NSWCA 394
- Chase Oyster Bar Pty Ltd v Hamo Industries Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 190